I'm giving it to Rosenda, but not by much. 7/10. The setting favors her over Eve. A small village won't have many great vantage points to shoot from, and the forest and village provide plenty of cover. Eve is better at long range with her powerful canon and great eyesight, while Rosenda operates better at middle and short range. She'd have a decently easy time getting in on Eve and pelting her with her mid-range weapons. The only question is if she pulls out the big guns, the only ones capable of actually killing Eve, in time, giving Eve a few wins when the duckfoot shotgun can put her down and she gets to throw a grenade.
Smarts: Yuu is definitely the smarter of the two by a lot.
Skill: Elatha is a jack of all trades, while Yuu has arguably better skill with her weapons of choice
stats: I think Elatha outclasses Yuu in most stats, particularly in raw strength.
Kit: Elatha has a more balanced kit, Yuu's is potent and straightforward, but Elatha has defensive skills like pentagrams and healing that can mitigate a lot of the damage done by her, and Yuu still lacks something that can put her down before she can counter.
I would say it could go either way, but the stage favors Elatha, given it forces them to clash directly.
I'm going Elatha 6/10
Anemone vs Sarah
Fight at the black and white forest (Dense forest in monochromatic tones, there is no sound, save for the ones characters make)
they start at random locations, have to track and hunt the other. (1 mile radius)
Going with Sarah 8.5/10 times. She is far more experienced than Anemone, and has a wider arsenal to deal with her tricks. The short range teleports will also serve to mask her movements better when tracking Anemone down, and in the fight itself.
Ashlea vs Loveline
Winner via KO or give up. Location: A grassy clearing in the middle of a forest.
Both in character.
Round 1: Only base Love Round 2: Gem form allowed for the normal time limit.
Fun round: Ashlea gets Alexis's help, and Love gets Arthur's. Still in character.
Ashlea wins first round due to smarts and firepower
second goes to Love in gem form. far more versatility.
for the second round, i think things are a bit more interesting, Ashlea lacks flight unlike the rest here, so if Arthur and Love play their cards right, they can potentially isolate Alexis and beat her.
on the other hand, If Ashlea and Alexis deal with Arthur quickly, they might get a swift win.
50/50 for the last round.
Amelia vs Leor Both in character and want to win win by KO or give up
Leor has several more years of training under his belt compared to Amelia, and his anti magic powers make her fire spells virtually useless against him. So he would likely beat her in CQC. It is for this reason I think Leor would win 70/30 to Ame, who could probably squeak out a win if she's clever with teleports.
Callis(current) and Jun vs Musashi in Return of the Unrivaled. What if Callis replaced Akabane as a combatant. Fight on my pyramid the original fight did. Winner via death or KO. Everyone in character.
Giving this one to Dan. Armand gets hurt each time he uses his powers, and while he may have the range and speed advantage...Dan is a tank who is skilled with martial arts. Just has to tank hits until Armand tires out enough to grab and end things.
With two fireballs, Anna has every advantage on Osechi. She's faster, smarter, and has more range with the fireballs, letting her close and stab Osechi a bunch. 8/10 Anna, Osechi might catch her by surprise a few times with a bite or air slash.
This one is surprisingly close. If this is current Stheno who can't use her eyes, that makes things more even. Sid's more agile than Stheno, and his armor can help protect him from her nails. But Stheno is also a bit smarter, and can still use Fortress Crusher to hit Sid through his armor. I would have to say...55/45 Sid. If Stheno gets full use of her eyes though, that changes to 70/30 Stheno.
A rematch: Sid vs Cadence.
Sid now has full use of his Gainen armor, and Cadence has her Gainen. They have full memory of the last time they fought. In character.
Fight until death or KO.
Location: A long grassy landscape of rolling hills.